Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
How I Started Making Overnight Yogurt in My Instant Pot Without Even Trying
60
items Spending $7 on a tiny cup of Greek yogurt every other day was bleeding my grocery budget dry — and half the store-bought stuff had ingredient lists longer than my arm. If you've been curious about homemade yogurt but assumed it required babysitting a...
Sections
12
Instant Pots With a Yogurt Setting
Milk That Actually Makes Good Yogurt
Starter Cultures That Won't Let You Down
Thermometers for Hitting the Right Temp
Strainers for Turning Regular Yogurt Into Greek
Sweeteners and Mix-Ins I Actually Use
Instant Pots With a Yogurt Setting
Not every model actually has the yogurt button — I learned that the hard way after buying one without it and having to return it. These are the ones I've tested or friends swear by.
Grab this if you want the no-frills model that just works — the yogurt button is right there on the front and I've run it overnight at least 200 times without a single issue.
Customer reviews for Instant Pot 6Qt Duo Plus
Switch to this bigger version if you're making yogurt for a family of four or more — my sister feeds five kids with one batch and still has leftovers for smoothies.
Instant Pot 8Qt Duo Plus 9-in-1 Multi-Cooker
Use the custom temperature controls on this one if you're picky about yogurt thickness — I dial it to exactly the incubation temp and get consistent results every single time.
Customer reviews for Instant Pot 8Qt Pro 10-in-1 Slow Multi
Perfect for anyone who wants one appliance doing everything — made yogurt overnight then used the air fryer lid to crisp up granola the next morning. Two birds.
Instant Pot Duo Crisp Air Fryer Combo with Lid
Snag this if you're on a tighter budget but still want that yogurt function — paid less than the Pro and honestly the yogurt comes out identical.
Instant Pot 6Qt DUO 7-in-1 Multi-Cooker
Milk That Actually Makes Good Yogurt
Tried skim milk once and got watery sadness in a pot. The fat content matters way more than I expected, and these are what consistently give me thick, creamy results.
Keep a gallon of this on hand — whole milk gives you that thick, creamy yogurt texture and at this price you're making a gallon of yogurt for what one store cup costs.
Great Value Whole Vitamin D Milk, Gallon
Try this if you want yogurt so thick it stands up on a spoon without straining — the extra protein from ultra-filtration does something magical during incubation.
fairlife Lactose Free Ultra Filtered Whole Milk, 52 fl oz
Use this when you want to go organic without hunting down a specialty store — the ultra-pasteurized part means you can skip the heating step entirely, straight to incubation.
Organic Valley® Whole Vitamin D Milk, Half Gallon, 64 fl oz
Swap to this if whole milk feels too heavy for you — still makes decent yogurt, just strain it a bit longer through cheesecloth and you'll get close to Greek consistency.
Great Value, 2% Reduced Fat Milk, Gallon
Bring this home for the kids' batch — my daughter insists she can taste the difference between organic and regular yogurt and honestly she might not be wrong.
Horizon Organic 2% Reduced Fat Milk, 1 Gallon
Starter Cultures That Won't Let You Down
First three batches I made were total flops because I used a starter that was basically dead on the shelf. These actually contain live active cultures that do what they're supposed to.
Grab a single cup of this as your first starter — two tablespoons mixed into warm milk and eight hours later you've got yogurt that tastes better than what you started with.
FAGE Total All Natural Whole Milk Plain Greek Strained
Use this when you want a milder, less tangy flavor profile — the cultures in here are gentle and produce a yogurt my picky husband actually enjoys without drowning it in honey.
Stonyfield Organic Plain Whole Milk Probiotic Yogurt
Perfect for anyone who already buys this weekly — just save two spoonfuls from your current tub as starter and you'll never need to buy a full container again.
Chobani Whole Milk Greek Yogurt Plain 32 oz Tub
Switch to this powdered starter when you want to stop depending on store-bought yogurt entirely — one packet reactivates for months and the tang is perfectly balanced.
Cultures For Health Traditional Flavor Yogurt Starter Culture
Try this as starter if you like your yogurt on the creamier, almost custard-like side — the texture it produces overnight is ridiculous for how little effort goes in.
The Greek Gods, Greek Style Probiotic Yogurt, Plain, 32 oz
Thermometers for Hitting the Right Temp
Overheated my milk to 200°F once and killed everything. A good thermometer is the difference between yogurt and expensive warm milk sitting on your counter.
Keep this in your kitchen drawer — reads the milk temp in three seconds flat so you know exactly when to add your starter without guessing or hovering nervously.
ThermoPro TP03 Digital Instant Read Meat Thermometer
Snag this cheap backup thermometer because you will lose your main one in a drawer eventually — happened to me twice and I almost ruined a batch both times.
Taylor Digital Meat Thermometer, Folding Probe
Use this waterproof version if you're clumsy like me — dropped my old thermometer directly into the milk pot once and had to start over. This one survives the chaos.
THERMOPRO TP19H IP65 Waterproof Meat Digital
Toss this in your apron pocket while you prep — the backlit screen means you can check milk temp even when the kitchen lights are dimmed at 10 PM before bed.
KIZEN Digital Meat Thermometer with Probe
Grab this for anyone who doesn't trust digital — the analog dial is foolproof and my mom prefers it because she says digital thermometers lie. They don't, but okay Mom.
CDN ProAccurate Quick-Read Thin Tip Thermometer, Red
Strainers for Turning Regular Yogurt Into Greek
Straight out of the Instant Pot, your yogurt is more like European-style — thin and pourable. Straining for a couple hours is what gets you that thick Greek yogurt texture.
Pair this with your Instant Pot routine and you'll have thick Greek yogurt by lunch — just pour the warm yogurt in, refrigerate, and the whey drains out on its own.
Cuisipro Donvier Yogurt Cheese Maker
Perfect if you want a dedicated strainer that fits neatly over a container — no more balancing cheesecloth over a bowl and hoping it doesn't collapse into the whey.
Euro Cuisine, GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker, 2 quarts capacity
Use the medium one lined with a coffee filter for straining yogurt — costs way less than a dedicated yogurt strainer and you'll use the other sizes for pasta and flour.
Zulay Kitchen 304 Stainless Steel Fine Mesh Strainer 3.35in
Try this if your fridge space is tight — strain the yogurt right over the sink for the first hour, then transfer to a bowl. Collapses flat for storage, which saved my tiny kitchen.
Prepworks by Progressive Collapsible Over-The-Sink Dish
Toss a layer of cheesecloth in this and set it over any bowl you own — dead simple, no fancy equipment needed, and the mesh is fine enough that you won't lose yogurt into the whey.
Mainstays 8 in Stainless Steel Fine Mesh Strainer, Silver
Sweeteners and Mix-Ins I Actually Use
Plain homemade yogurt is tangy and honest, but sometimes you want it to taste like dessert without adding a cup of white sugar. These are my go-to flavor additions.
Drizzle this into your yogurt right before eating, not before incubation — learned the hard way that honey can kill the cultures if you add it too early. Tastes incredible though.
Nate's, Organic Honey, 32 oz Bottle, Raw Unfiltered Honey
Swap to this if honey is too floral for your taste — dissolves instantly into cold yogurt without any gritty texture and has a clean sweetness that doesn't overpower the tang.
Madhava, Organic Amber Blue Agave, 23.5 oz Bottle
Add half a teaspoon per cup after the yogurt is done — smells like actual vanilla ice cream and makes my kids think they're eating dessert for breakfast. Parenting win.
Great Value Pure Vanilla Extract, 1 fl oz
Keep this around for guests who just want regular sweetened yogurt without the fuss — a tablespoon stirred in and it tastes exactly like the flavored cups at the store.
Wholesome Organic Cane Sugar (6 lbs.)
Use this if you're watching sugar intake — zero glycemic impact and honestly after a week of using it I stopped noticing any difference from regular sugar in my morning bowl.
Lakanto Classic Monkfruit Sweetener 28.22 oz (Pack of 8)
Toppings That Make Breakfast Worth Waking Up For
Yogurt alone is fine. Yogurt with the right toppings is the reason I stopped hitting snooze and actually look forward to mornings now.
Throw a handful on top right before you eat — adding it too early turns it into mush. The berry clusters with fresh homemade yogurt honestly ruined store-bought parfaits for me forever.
Bear Naked Fit Triple Berry Crunch Granola 12 oz Bag
Toss these on for crunch without the sweetness of granola — toasted in a dry pan for two minutes they go from fine to incredible, and they keep for months in the pantry.
Great Value Sliced Almonds, 4 oz
Sprinkle a tablespoon in and wait five minutes — they plump up and add this tapioca-like texture that makes your yogurt feel way more filling. Kept me full until lunch when nothing else did.
Navitas Organics Chia Seed Powder, 8oz
Pull these out of the freezer the night before and let them thaw in the fridge — by morning they're perfectly soft and their juice swirls into the yogurt like a natural fruit syrup.
Frozen Berries Selection with Strawberries Cranberries
Grab the giant bear if you're going through honey fast — at the rate I was drizzling the small bottle I was buying a new one every two weeks. This lasts months.
Honey: Automatic Coupons, Promo Codes, and Deals
Glass Jars for Storing and Portioning Yogurt
Made a huge batch once and shoved it all in one giant container. Scooping out portions every morning got messy fast. Individual jars changed the whole routine.
Portion your yogurt into these right after straining — grab one jar each morning and you've got a perfect single serving. The lids seal tight enough to toss in a work bag without leaking.
Mainstays Mason Jars 16 oz Regular Mouth 12 Pack
Use these if you want something wider than a mason jar — easier to spoon toppings in and eat directly from the container without getting yogurt all over your knuckles.
(6 pack) Anchor Hocking Glass Food Storage Containers
Perfect for anyone who wants multiple sizes — small ones for yogurt portions, bigger ones for storing the full batch. The snap lids actually stay on, which sounds basic but matters.
Pyrex 18-piece Glass Food Storage Container Set with Lids
Keep these for storing the full unstrained batch overnight — wide mouth means you can pour thick yogurt in and out without it getting stuck at the narrow top.
Ball, Glass Mason Jar, 32 Oz. Quart, Regular Mouth 12-Count
Bring these out when you want your homemade yogurt to look like it came from a fancy brunch spot — the glass clips make a satisfying snap and they look beautiful in the fridge.
Weck Tulip Jar - Single 1-Liter Jar
Cheesecloth and Nut Milk Bags for Straining
Paper towels disintegrate. Regular kitchen towels leave lint. Learned both of those lessons the gross way before landing on proper straining materials.
Drape this over your strainer and let gravity do the work — ultra fine weave means no yogurt escapes through and you can rinse and reuse it at least a dozen times before replacing.
Regency Wraps Natural Ultra Fine Cheesecloth
Switch to this if cheesecloth feels wasteful — one bag lasts months, strains yogurt beautifully, and you can throw it in the washing machine between uses.
Pro Quality Nut Milk Bag - 5 XL12"X12" Bags
Grab this grade 90 specifically — lower grades let too much through and you end up with thin yogurt and a frustrated morning. The tight weave makes all the difference.
Dritz, Cotton Cheesecloth, Food Grade, 36in x 6 Yards
Use this nylon version if cotton bags weird you out — dries faster, doesn't hold odors, and the drawstring top means you can actually squeeze out extra whey without making a mess.
Ellie's Best Pro Quality Nut Milk Bag - XL 12" x 12" 5 Pack
Keep this bulk roll around for when you're making large batches — fold it in half for finer straining and you've still got enough material to last six months easily.
Burlap Fabric Packaged Cheesecloth Grade 50
Silicone Accessories That Fit Inside the Pot
Scratched my stainless steel inner pot with a metal spoon once and spent twenty minutes scrubbing yogurt residue out of the scratch lines. Silicone everything after that.
Use the flat-edge spatula to scrape every last bit of yogurt from the pot — wasting even a tablespoon used to bug me and now I get it all out cleanly without scratching anything.
Star Pack Ultra Flexible Silicone Rubber Turner Spatula
Keep this on during incubation instead of the heavy pressure lid — it's lighter, doesn't lock and scare you at midnight, and lets just enough warmth stay trapped for perfect fermentation.
Instant Pot Lid 6 Quart(11)
Swap your ring out every few months — mine started smelling like garlic from last week's curry and that smell was getting into my yogurt. Dedicated ring for yogurt, separate one for savory.
4 Pack Sealing Ring 6 Qt for Instant Pot
Stir your heated milk with these without worrying about melting — the heat resistance is real and the flexible edge gets into the corners of the pot where milk likes to scorch.
U-Taste 600°F High Heat Resistant Silicone Spoon
Portion hot yogurt into jars with this instead of pouring from the heavy pot — way more control, no splashing, and my counter stays clean for once.
OXO Good Grips Silicone Everyday Spatula - Non-Stick
Cleaning Supplies for the Inner Pot
Yogurt residue bonds to stainless steel like it has a personal vendetta. Regular dish soap barely touches it. These actually get the pot back to shiny without destroying the surface.
Sprinkle this in your inner pot after a yogurt batch and watch the film disappear — took my pot from cloudy and gross back to mirror-finish in about thirty seconds of light scrubbing.
Bar Keepers Friend Cleanser Powder 21 OZ
Pair these with Bar Keepers Friend and you'll never scratch your pot — the blue side is abrasive enough for dried yogurt but gentle enough that the steel stays smooth.
Scotch-Brite, Cleaning Sponges, Blue
Spray this directly on dried yogurt residue and walk away for five minutes — come back and it wipes off with almost no scrubbing. Wish someone told me about this a year ago.
Dawn, Powerwash Spray, 16 Fl Oz
Use this for the spots the sponge can't reach — the narrow head gets into the rim groove where whey likes to dry into a crusty ring that haunts you if you ignore it.
OXO Good Grips Dish Brush, White/Black, 1EA
Wipe down the outside of your Instant Pot with these after splatter happens — keeps the housing looking new instead of developing that yellowed sticky film around the buttons.
Weiman Stainless Steel Cleaner Wipes Fingerprint
Books and Resources That Taught Me Everything
Watched about forty YouTube videos with conflicting advice before finding actual reliable sources. These gave me consistent results and helped me stop guessing.
Read the yogurt chapter before your first batch — it explains the science behind incubation times in plain English and saved me from the overfermented sour disaster I was heading toward.
The Instant Pot Bible : More than 350 Recipes and Strategies
Grab this if you learn better from photos than text — every step has a picture and the yogurt section specifically addresses common mistakes that nobody warns you about online.
Jeffrey Eisner, Instant Pot Cookbook, Step-By-Step
Use the flavor variation section to branch out once you've nailed plain — the vanilla bean and honey lavender recipes in here made me realize homemade yogurt can taste like anything you want.
Amy's Instant Pot Adventure
Try the dahi recipe in this book if you want traditional Indian-style yogurt — completely different culture and technique than Greek, milder tang, and incredible with rice or as a marinade base.
Indian Instant Pot Cookbook: Traditional Dishes
Perfect for couples or anyone living solo who doesn't need five quarts of yogurt — the scaled-down recipes mean less waste and you're eating it at peak freshness instead of day five leftovers.
Janet A Zimmerman, Instant Pot cookbook for Two